Thursday, September 16, 2004, 10:47 pm
Pants of fire: Survivor Week 1

Boom! Lava and ash spew into the air. An aerial shot zooms in on a tiny figure making his way across the precariously narrow lip of a volcanic crater. It’s our hero, Probst, and he’s as unflappable as ever. We cut to a close-up. He’s delivering his now-familiar speech: Vanuatu is an island nation, blah blah blah, fascinating history, blah blah blah. A gigantic cloud of ash is exploding just over his shoulder.
He keeps yapping about the adventure of a lifetime as we cut to a helicopter shot of an improbably tiny boat cutting through the waters off the Vanuatuese … Vanuatuan … Vanuatoid … off the island’s coast. Eighteen players this time, instead of sixteen. Three tribes of six, like on last season’s “Let’s give Rupert a second — no, third! — chance” outing? It’s a pretty standard Survivor crowd. There’s the blonde that’s going to be co-hosting “The View” in about twenty minutes. There’s the Ani DiFranco chick with the nose piercing. There’s the pudgy nerd in the ironic tee shirt. There’s the ex-military guy with the practiced thousand-yard stare of the functional sociopath. And three or four totally interchangeable boys with chiseled jaws and five-o’clock shadows and, no doubt, bodies handpicked to bring in the female 18-24 demo like bees to a honeysuckle bush.
Cut back to Probst standing before the mouth of Hell itself. “Thirty nine days, eighteen people, one survivor.” Yeah, I know, the math doesn’t work out. In previous seasons they’ve culled the herd once every three days, but they’ve only started with sixteen. They’re going to do something different this time around. Obviously.
Pull back to a wide, wide, really wide shot — look, it’s not a soundstage! — and smash cut to the credits, credits which prominently feature bungie jumping, volcanoes, outrigger canoes, and people with mud on their faces. Titles come up identifying each and every one of the eighteen adorable little scamps who, if the clips are any indication, are going to spend the next six weeks not bathing at all.
The boat with our contestants on it drops anchor in a cove a few hundred yards off of a pristine, white beach devoid of … wait a minute. This new. There are natives! The beach is positively swarming with islanders. The contestants and the islanders stare at each other for a second, then the Waponis take to their outrigger canoes and, yelling at the top of their lungs, start paddling out toward the boat. The contestants all picture the headline on page A3 of the Times: “Television cast wiped out by enraged Vanuatuans … Vanuatuis … islanders.”

CAPTION: Has perfect cleavage
Turns out it’s not nearly that interesting of an opening, but it’s not bad. After a breathless pep talk from Probst, the contestants board the canoes — inevitably, the nerd in the ironic vintage tee manages to take his canoe-mates for an unplanned swim — and head for the beach. Brunette #3 talks in voice-over about how she was “moved to tears” by the experience, which makes me wonder if visitors to America get “moved to tears” by their first ride in a taxi.
The rest of the gang heroically maintains their composure long enough to assemble on the beach. The moment they set foot on sand, a couple dozen Waponis in honest-to-God grass skirts run out whooping like crazy and brandishing spears. Rather than skewering the contestants and firing up the barbecue pit, the Waponis separate them into two groups by means of a complex ritual steeped in tradition, a practice anthropologists call “boy-girl, boy-girl.”
The men are led off thisa-way to their seats, and the women are led off thata-way to theirs. Cue the obligatory remarks about gender segregation from brunette #2, who would ordinarily have earned my scorn as a shrill harpy were it not for the fact that she displayed the most amazing cleavage ever broadcast on national television. You know how TiVo has that ten-second-instant-replay button on the remote? I’m happy to testify that mine works perfectly.
The boys are given kava, which is Waponi for “muddy water with twigs and dead bugs floating in it, plus vodka.” The sun goes down, there’s a square dance, a pig is sacrificed — I’m so not kidding — and the boys are anointed with its blood. Which, if you consider the fact that these guys aren’t gonna see a shower for the next six weeks, is a little on the nasty side. Amazing-cleavage-girl — who we might as well remember is called Eliza, ‘cause ain’t no way she’s goin’ anywhere for a while — expresses shock. Her remarks, which coming from anybody else would be vapid and tedious, are strangely compelling to me. “Go on,” I mumble, but they cut away from her.

CAPTION: Most likely to have killed someone for fun
Which brings me to my next point. Blonde-girl-who’s-going-to-be-a-talk-show-host-any-minute-now describes herself as a “shepherdess.” The Chyron calls her a “sheep farmer,” which I guess really should have been “sheep farmess,” though the AP style book is strangely silent on that point. She’s got adorable little pigtails and perfect skin and she talks at great length about slaughtering lambs. Cut back to a reaction shot of the pig sacrifice. Brunette #5 looks horrified. Dolly-the-sheep-farmess is completely glazed over, bored out of her mind at the whole thing. What I’m trying to get across here is that this is one scary chick. Imagine Mary Ann crossed with Hannibal Lecter.
Once the boys are all well smeared with hot pig blood, along comes Probst to give some kind of a speech about a rock. I wasn’t really listening so I couldn’t tell you exactly why the rock is important, but it doesn’t really matter because it turns out it’s just a pretense for a stunt. One of the Waponis shimmies up a telephone pole that has been, we are told, smeared with pig fat. He plops the rock into a basket on the top of the pole. Probst looks over at the boys and gleefully tells ‘em to fetch the rock. The chief of the Waponis picks one of the boys, seemingly by virtue of the fact that he’s sitting on the end of his bench. It happens to be one of the interchangeable Kens who the Chyron identifies as Brady, an FBI agent. For purposes of this column, he will be known as Chet Beefpile.
Chet rubs his hands and feet with sand and … climbs the pole. Seriously, he positively scampers up the thing like it’s something he does every day. He grabs the rock and slides on down looking singularly pleased with himself. Talk about an anti-climax.
Probst shuts the party down pretty quickly, shipping the boys off down the beach thata-way and the girls off thisa-way.
We’re off on a commercial break. There’s a promo for “CSI: New York,” which I’m actually kinda looking forward to because I like Gary Sinese so much. Turns out they’re using “Baba O’Reilly” for the theme this time around. What a crime that a truly great song like “Won’t Get Fooled Again” has to be bolted on to as crappy a show as “CSI: Miami.”
Back from commercial, and the crew has broken out their night-vision goggles. The boys are walking and bickering. The girls, by way of contrast, are walking and bickering. Nothing happens for four solid minutes. Eventually both groups get where they’re going and they do one of those neat dissolves to mark the passage of time. Cutting edge editorial it ain’t, but whatever. The Chyron pops up ominously: Day 2. Which I think is such a cheat. Day 1 was really just a few hours. It shouldn’t count as a full day.
The next morning, the girls are building their shelter. They’ve watched Survivor before, evidently, because they’ve got the whole gabled-roof with palm-frond thatching thing down pat. One of the girls says, “We’ve got a sturdy rack for our shelter,” and just as she says the word “rack” the editor treats us to a down-blouse shot of Brunette #1. Don’t even try to tell me it was a coincidence, either.
At this point we get the required parable of the ants and the grasshopper. These girls are sweating under the oppressive jungle canopy to build the shelter. Those girls are sunning themselves on the beach. Remember, children: the Protestant work ethic is good. Industry is the only virtue.
I’m not buying it, though, because the girls who are building the shelter are the hausfraus and the girls are playing in the surf are the swimsuit models, including perfect-cleavage-girl Eliza. If I were there, my ass would be playing in the surf too, work ethic be damned.
Meanwhile the guys are trying to start a fire. One of the Kens did a Google on it before leaving the house the previous morning, and constructs himself a little fire-starting device. A little sweat, a little elbow grease and a few minutes later they’ve got themselves an ember. But they don’t blow on it just right and it goes out, at which point they … stop. They just stop trying to build a fire. Despite the fact that, you know, it worked, and they almost had an actual fire going, they just call it a day. Baffling.

CAPTION: No longer fully human
Then comes the Big Reveal. One of the boys pulls off his pants to reveal that he’s wearing a prosthetic leg from just below his knee down. Because everything I know about prostheses I learned from “Star Wars,” I can only conclude that he’s more machine than man, twisted and evil. He somehow manages to conceal his evil long enough to tell the story of how he lost his leg — cancer, it turns out — and to make everybody else feel like asses for whining and complaining while one-leg-boy sucks it up and plays the game. The consensus is that Cyborg Chad, as he will from now on be known, will be a force to reckon with in this game.
Another commercial. The curly-haired guy from the Drew Carey show lands a supermodel girlfriend. That’s why it’s called fiction, people.
When we come back from the break, it’s suddenly Day 3. There’s no discussion of where these people are getting their food or their drinking water. I guess they’re all hungry and thirsty … which, it turns out, explains a lot about what we’re about to see.
The tribes assemble on the beach for their ridiculously elaborate challenge. As the boys walk up, the girls all check out Cyborg Chad’s prosthesis … if you know what I mean. I’m pretty sure I heard one of the girls mutter, “How far up does that thing—” before getting an elbow in the ribs from a teammate.
The ridiculously elaborate challenge is, indeed, ridiculously elaborate. It involves an obstacle course with a crawling component and a balancing component, and then there’s some stuff with a marble maze and a fire pit and a torch and another fire … whatever. Survivor challenges have gone from being tests of skill and luck to something out of a Japanese game show. How’s this for a challenge: build a fire. Huh? How about that? How about this one: catch a fish. Let’s get this thing back to the real spirit of the game. Here’s your challenge for the day: first one to find some food wins.
But no, instead we’re running an obstacle course. The reward for winning, Probst announces, is a piece of flint that can be used to light a fire. He also unveils the immunity symbol, which appears to be a spear decorated with an actual human pelvis.
Ready, set, go. The contestants crawl and get very muddy. Then they do a puzzle that’s not really even worth describing; rather than being a test of logic or wit it seems to just be a test of not being a total spaz. Then they scale a rope net and cross a narrow beam. And when I say narrow, I mean narrow. The Olympics were just a few weeks ago; we all sat and watched little girls dance on the balance beam. The gymnastic balance beam is four inches across. This beam might have been half of that. It looks like nothing so much as a two-by-eight turned sideways. One of the Kens crosses it barefoot, literally gripping it between his toes to maintain his balance. It’s actually a pretty impressive trick.
And here, Constant Reader, is where the wheels come off the wagon for the boys’ team. The last of the boys, Chris, simply can’t make it across the beam. He tries it on foot, he tries it on his belly, he just can’t make it. Even Cyborg Chad made it across, but Chris just can’t do it. Meanwhile the girls get their last hausfrau across — and give us our first wardrobe malfunction of the game, incidentally — and surge into the lead.
The rest of it, the crap with the fire and whatever, is just irrelevant, because when Probst triumphantly declares the girls the winner and hands them their goodies, Chris is still trying to shimmy his way across that damn beam.
Another commercial. It’s a department-store spot that is, I swear to God, the creepiest thing I’ve ever seen in my life. Mannequins shouldn’t move. They shouldn’t walk around. They damn sure shouldn’t play footsie. It may have been a local insert, however, so those in other markets may have been spared the horror.
Back to the boys’ beach, and everybody’s talking about whether to go through the motions at tribal council or just murder Chris now and feast on his corpse. To his credit, though, Chris has a sense of humor about it. “To tell you guys a little bit more about myself, I’m not real good at the balance beam.” Cut to a montage of boys wandering around camp including a quick shot of what looks like one of the Kens masturbating. I’m completely serious. Why not, after all? We’ve seen a pig killed, its blood smeared over people’s faces, and Eliza’s perfect cleavage. Why not just go for it?
Around the camp, there are conversations. The Kens are going to vote for Chris. That’s a given. Some of the others profess that they’re still on the fence, but they’re going to vote for Chris too. I mean, come on. He fumbled the ball on the five-yard-line. He’s going home. All this stuff is just filler to pad out the hour.
But Chris, bless ‘em, isn’t going gently into that good night. He’s working the votes so hard you’d think he’s trying to get a budget bill passed. He and the Sarge confer and agree that their best bet is to vote for one of the Kens, the one named Brook. Yeah, yeah, I know. It’s a girl’s name. But it’s okay, see, because his momma dropped the “e” at the end of it when she named him, thereby making it a boy’s name. Sure, man. Whatever you need to believe to be able to sleep at night.
The boys head off for what’s apparently an hour-long hike to tribal council, because they leave before sunset and arrive at dusk. The tribal council set always looks like the producers spent a million bucks on it, and maybe they did. Then again, if the lighting’s bad enough you can get away with a lot on television.
The boys go through the now-familiar ritual of lighting their torches and taking their seats. Probst gets to play talk-show host for a few minutes. “Chris, at any point did you think, ‘I’m dead?’” “Rory, how are you fitting in with the group?” “Senator, are you now or have you ever been a communist?” That kind of thing.
Enough chit-chat; it’s time to vote. One by one the nine boys trudge off to cast their super-secret ballots. Brook, the Ken with the girl’s name, casts his vote for Chris and mumbles something that even after repeated viewings I can’t begin to make out. Chris casts his vote for Brook, confessing that Brook is the only other player in the tribe whose name Chris knows. Then again, he may have said something about how it’s all a part of the game, but my inborn vapidness filter edited it out and replaced it with something more entertaining.

CAPTION: Chump
Probst counts the votes. Surprisingly, it’s not five votes in a row for Chris. The voting is actually pretty even: three votes for Chris, three for Brook, and one for Ralph Nader. (“The ballot was confusing,” the anonymous player is quoted as saying.) But the last two votes go to Brook, and for the first time in Survivor history we have an upset on the very first night.
Cut to a long close-up of one of the Kens with his chin on his palm and beads of sweat on his forehead as he strains to absorb the thought: “Five is more than three.”
“The tribe has spoken,” Brook. Get your girly-named ass out of here.
Over the closing credits they play a tape of the just-ousted Brook saying, “The one thing I didn’t want was to be the first person off.” Well, look at the bright side, girly-named Brook. At least you got beat by a strong competitor … oh. Yeah. Never mind.
Next week, perfect-cleavage Eliza will be heard to say, “Being here is like being in prison.” Judging by all the all-girl prison movies I’ve seen on the special channel late at night, you can be sure I’ll tune in!
Correction
The original draft of this article incorrectly stated that the gymnastic balance beam is four feet across. I was, obviously, off by a factor of twelve. The error has been corrected. I generally don’t post correction notices about typos like this, but this one made me laugh when a reader informed me of it, so I thought “What the heck.”

